興趣愛好If you’re on the search for a formula that simply will not budge, your best bet is to opt for a waterproof liner. Similar to that of your waterproof mascara, these products ensure maximum staying power when opting for a graphic line or bold winged look; plus, ink and liquid liners will offer more pigment. The best eyeliners allow to you to create a variety of eye looks sans skipping or tugging. The Shop TODAY team spoke to celebrity makeup artists and beauty influencers to better understand what causes eyeliner to smudge and what to look for in smudge-proof eyeliners. We used their expert insights and recommendations to round up the best smudge-proof eyeliners. Additionally, we asked our editors for their favorite picks they trust. It should be noted that all of the best white eyeliners for waterline that we’ve recommended below are also great for anywhere around the eyes. The reason that these are specifically recommended for waterline has to do with their formula.